Yeah, well I can see where you're coming from since I'm such a sheep, you know. I mean, just look at my 2006 year-end list. Full of critics' faves. Might as well just cut and paste the Pitchfork list:
1 – J. Tillman – Long May You Run
2 - Knife – Silent Shout
3 - Centro-matic – Fort Recovery
4 - Eric Bachmann – To the Races
5 - J. Tillman – Minor Works
(Encre – Encre A Kora EP)
6 - Nathan Fake – Drowning In A Sea of Love
7 - Elephant Micah – Embarrassment of Riches / Tropical Depression EP
8 - Ms John Soda – Notes and the Like
9 - Travel By Sea – Shadows Rise
10 – Hypatia Lake – ...And We Shall Call Him Joseph
11 – Thom Yorke – Eraser
12 – Sparrow House – Falls EP
13 - Liz Durrett – The Mezzanine
14 – Richard Buckner – Meadow
15 – King Biscuit Time – Black Gold
16 – Matt Bauer – Wasps and White Roses EP
17 - Tenhi – Maaaet
18 - Espers – Espers II
19 – Brother Kite – Waiting For the Time To Be Right
20 – Jeffrey Foucalt – Ghost Repeater
--------------------------------------------------
To create man was a fine and original idea, but to add the sheep was a tautology.