Here is my list as of October. I do not forsee much of my top five changing by December 31!
<b>Top 20 Albums of the Year - Through October</b>
1. Deerhuter - Microcastle(iTunes version) - A+
2. Vampire Weekend - Vampire Weekend - A
3. TV on the Radio - Dear Science, - A-
4. Atlas Sound - Let the Blind Lead Those Who Can See But Cannot Feel - A-
5. Fleet Foxes - Fleet Foxes - B+
6. Department of Eagles - In Ear Park - B+
7. Nine Inch Nails - The Slip - B+
8. Plants and Animals - Parc Avenue - B
9. F*** Buttons - Street Horrrsing - B
10. Xiu Xiu - Women as Lovers - B
11. Horse Feathers - House With No Name - B
12. Hercules & Love Affair - Hercules & Love Affair - B
13. Lindstom - Where You Go I Go Too - B
14. Broken Social Scene Presents Brendan Canning - Something For All of Us - B
15. Antony and the Johnsons - Another World(EP) - A-
16. DeVotchka - A Mad and Faithful Telling - B-
17. Sigur Ros - Með Suð Í Eyrum Við Spilum Endalaust - B-
18. Belong - Colorless Record(EP) - B
19. Clientele - That Night a Forest Grew(EP) - B+
20. Deastro - Keeper's - B-
Note about my scoring... I hold EPs to a different standard that LPs, so some of the EPs on here have a higher score than the surrounding LPs.
<b>Best Songs of the Year - Through October</b>
1. Agoraphobia - Deerhunter
2. Golden Age - TV on the Radio
3. Transliterator - DeVotchka
4. Colours Move - F*** Buttons
5. Winter Vacation - Atlas Sound
6. White Winter Hymnal - Fleet Foxes
7. Echoplex - Nine Inch Nails
8. Gobbledigook - Sigur Ros
9. you are pregnant, you are dead - Xiu Xiu
10. Walcott - Vampire Weekend
11. Churches Under the Stairs - BSS Presents Brendan Canning
12. Cut Copy - Far Away
13. Matmos - Supreme Balloon
14. Touch Me I'm Going To Scream Pt. 2 - My Morning Jacket
15. Navy Sheets - The Hold Steady
16. Crackagen - Antony and the Johnsons
17. That Night a Forest Grew - The Clientele
18. Late Night - Belong
19. Superserious Supersonic - REM
20. Spookhouse - Clear Tigers
For my list of top songs, I only chose one song per album. If I did multiple songs per album, there would be a LOT more from Microcastle (Deerhunter), Vampire Weekend, and And Let the Blind... (Atlas Sound).
Overall, this year has been a huge letdown compared to the ridiculous awesomeness that was 2007. Luckily, though, things have been turning around in the past couple of months. I am blown away by the Department of Eagles album (no surprise considering the contributors), the new TV on the Radio rocks my world, and everyone should really give the Antony and the Johnsons EP a listen.
My favorite artist of the year is clearly Bradford Cox. For the longest time this year Atlas Sound was my favorite album of the year. Then I discovered Microcastle on iTunes (early release) and that changed rather quickly! Oh my god. What an amazing album. I can not be more happy with the way Microcastle turned out. Lyrically it is genious, especially Agoraphobia. Musically these guys are at the top of their game, absolutely. Such a full, enjoyable record. My new favorite artist, and right up there with Ed Droste and Owen Pallet for me for awesome queer artists of the past decade.
Golden Age by TV on the Radio is obviously a hoot (see the music video!). Another song that is worth mention is Transliterator by DeVotchka, the most unexpectedly awesome track off an OK-ish album for me. I know that there has been a lot of Vampire Weekend backlash, but I can't help it. It's one of my most consistently listened-to albums of the year. So many great songs on it, not a stinker in the bunch. Even minor/short songs on the album are marvelous. I just love that crunchy-pop sound. Also of worthy mention is Nine Inch Nails' The Slip. So good. I know that Ghosts I-IV did not go over well for a lot of people (see the Metacritic rating), but I don't think that Ghosts was even intended as a real NIN "album." The Slip, however, is, and it is marvelous, though a little too short. If only With Teeth and The Slip could be combined somehow...
OK year, just no 2007! Still have not heard anything on par with MIA - Kala or PJ Harvey - White Chalk. Speaking of, where are the great female-led albums from this year? The new Breeders album I though was good, and I know there have been a few recent releases such as the Vivian Girls that have been really good. I think MIA should release a new album every year (wishful thinking).
"Be yourself. Unless you suck."
-Buffy, "Buffy the Vampire Slayer"