Here are a few of the best Christian artists that come to mind that I have listened to over the years, past and present.
Five Iron Frenzy - got into these guys right around 1997, ska/rock stuff but don't lump them in with the load of crappy Christian ska/rock bands that were around at the same time. Intelligent lyrics, competent musicianship, the Frenzy had it all. Favorite album:
Upbeats and Beatdowns .
Stavesacre - still together, and have made several great albums. Hard rock, with huge guitars and drums, beautifully soaring and searing music. Favorite album:
Speakeasy .
Rose Blossom Punch - only released two albums, one of which I can't find anywhere. But the one I have is a real doozy. Beautifully melodic rock, a real overlooked gem. Favorite album:
Ephemere .
Sufjan Stevens - you've already heard of him, undoubtedly, but out of all these artists, it's most important that you listen to him. Any and all of his albums are spectacular. My personal favorite is
Illinois . And no, he doesn't really fit under the Christian music moniker since he isn't confined to that in terms of what he writes about, but his Christianity certainly comes through in a lot of his songs. Don't be too mad at me, Sufjan. You're amazing.
Mike Knott - you have probably never heard of him, but this guy is one hell of a songwriter. Very prolific, playing in many bands, but his solo albums are where his best songs are found. Kind of a general rock feel to his songs, but his lyrics are wonderful. Definitely check out
Strip Cycle and if you can find it
Rocket and a Bomb . Great stuff.
Over the Rhine - again I'm hesitant to lump this artist in the specifically Christian scene, but they do write about Christian themes throughout their many albums. Gorgeous female vocals (one of my favorite voices even), and every album sounds different (sometimes good, sometimes less good, lol). Tons of albums, but my favorites are
Good Dog, Bad Dog ,
Ohio , and
Drunkard's Prayer .
The Violet Burning - can't speak for any of their newer albums, but their early ones are really awesome. Kind of a Smashing Pumpkins vibe, but much different singing voice and not as guitar-focused on some of their releases. Definitely check out their self-titled album and also
demonstrates plastic and elastic .
That's all that comes to mind right now, hope this was helpful somehow.
Not all those who wander are lost.