What the fuck? During the months they were doing this movie didn't anybody that took part in this take a step back and ask what the hell is going on here? Not necessarily bad, just a very confused movie and a big disappointment after the awesomeness of Dead Man's Chest.

I found the movie to be exciting and entertaining. After watching the second movie 5 times I finally understood all the plot points. I knew that the third movie would be super confusing plot wise, so I paid super close attention to it.

hmm, still haven't seen it. worth seeing?

quote:

Originally posted by Cornbread1:
hmm, still haven't seen it. worth seeing?

I think so! Strange that some found the last 2 confusing, I didn't. There are a few things that aren't all that great, but I had a good time. The battle at sea at the end of the movie was the best in the series! I'm just disappointed there weren't more ships involved. Why did they all show up if only the Black Pearl & the Flying Dutchman were going to be the only ones fighting? Awww, who cares! It was cool anyway!

After seeing Lohan's farce of a mystery/horror??? I Know Who Killed Me, a movie will have to be extremely terrible to win the worst of 07.

I agree. Dead Mans' Chest was pretty good and the first movie was excellent but the 3rd one made absolutely no sense.

hmm i hate to disagree but I love this movie. I think Pirates of the Caribbean 3 answered all the questions in 1 and 2. By the way, have you seen the extra seen after the credits?

I saw this movie the other day, and I have to say it's one of the worst films I've ever seen. The story is completely incoherent and the action scenes are ridiculous.

I'll have to agree with Eric. It's even worse than the second one, which was mediocre at best. The first was decent though.

I never really liked any of the POTC movies...

I think POTC 3 Rocked! I don't understand why some people found it confusing.

I stopped after the first Pirates movie. I couldn't get over the fact that two dead pirates were sword fighting. Why the hell would two people who can't die be fighting? Seems like a waste of time.

Pride...Ego...but come on, it's fantasy, it's ment to be fun. You want logical watch the discover channel.

quote:

Originally posted by Humaren:
You want logical watch the discover channel.

There's a difference between logical and factual. Those of us ripping on the nonsensical plot realize its a fantasy movie, but the plot isn't logical in the sense that characters take actions and things happen for no apparent reason and without explanation.

Even in a film like Star Wars, that's not at all based in a world we know, the characters still follow a logical path.

quote:

Originally posted by Humaren:
Pride...Ego...but come on, it's fantasy, it's ment to be fun. You want logical watch the discover channel.

My main gripe with the first one was its length. It felt a half hour too long. And since the 2nd and 3rd installments were longer, I figured I'd save my money.

quote:

Originally posted by musicfanatic:
My main gripe with the first one was its length. It felt a half hour too long. And since the 2nd and 3rd installments were longer, I figured I'd save my money.

Now that I can not argue with! Although I liked all 3, they really could have shaved some time and lesser scenes off. Especially 3...way too long.

Okay, at some parts it dragged on but besides that I like it much.

I loved the movie and it's awesome!!!!!

quote:

Originally posted by Humaren:

quote:

Originally posted by musicfanatic:
My main gripe with the first one was its length. It felt a half hour too long. And since the 2nd and 3rd installments were longer, I figured I'd save my money.

Now that I can not argue with! Although I liked all 3, they really could have shaved some time and lesser scenes off. Especially 3...way too long.

You should be lucky that there's one movie which length is more than a day....... SERIOUSLY. There is one.

The series were alright. It was hard to see Depp play this role though after how great he was in Blow and Edward Scissorhands.