Actually, I feel the same way about it. They played a local venue, and Sinister and I went and checked it out. We had never heard of them, and had no preconceived notions. The place was packed, so, obviously, somebody had heard of them.
We were really impressed with the show. Very energetic, very percussion driven. I thought some of the vocals were a bit emo, but, in the context of the show, I didn't find it disturbing.
We bought the CD at the show, and, it is OK. Not earth shattering. Not top 20 for me for the year or anything like that. But OK.
I suspect if I had heard the album first, I wouldn't have been especially interested in seeing them. But since it happened the other way around, I'll listen to the album now and then.
---------------
I wonder if you're mythologizing me, like I do you