I just finished watching the season 2 finale of B.G. and I'm still stunned at how amazing that episode was. Literally, the writers should be up for an Emmy for that episode, and the acting was phenomenal. This is the third best show on TV in my opinion (#1 - The Wire (HBO), #2 - Lost (ABC)) If you haven't watched it, Netflix the miniseries, then buy the first season, and check out the second season on SCI-FI -- I'm no sci-fi nut, but I've loved it.

BSG would be #1 show on TV for me.

The only television show in recent history I've liked more is the first season of Sopranos. (But BSG is much better than the last two seasons).

I think the finale itself was a tad rushed though. It made the other ship look a tad less 'pessimistic vision of humanity' and a tad more just 'evil'.

But yes, if BSG maintains this quality for another season or two and has an ending as good as the setup, BSG could surpass TNG and B5 for the best scifi series ever.

I've been on that show in the background a couple of times, but I've still never seen an episode. The oriental cylon on the show is an incredible actress to watch in person, I heard she went to the high school I attended in Grade 9. All very nice people to deal with, and the lead actors were super nice to everyone.

One thing to add about BSG...

Ron Moore, the writer?

80% of my favorite episodes of Star Trek TNG have his name somewhere in the credits.

Buh.

Okay, I want to talk about the season finale with somebody, and the friend I talk about it with doesn't usually see it the night it airs because he doesn't have Scifi.

What the HELL?!

BSG might be turning into the least predictable science fiction show ever. It took the show in a direction I didn't even think of as a possibility.

The fleet settles on random planet in nebula and becomes complacent, a year passes, the cylons decide they don't want to slaughter humanity anymore, so much as rule over them as their masters?

Watching DS9, you can tell that Ron Moore wanted to explore the Cardassian occupation of Bajor more than he ever got to. I wonder if this plot turn is him saying "We're going to explore the morality of terrorism by putting the good guys in a situation where it's their only option. Don't like it? Screw you."

I can't wait for season three. Unfortunately it's not till OCTOBER!!!

HEY - home come Metacritic has not done a review summary of BSG???? Can anyone guess?? I mean they just did one for Doctor Who and every braindead reality show gets one. What gives?

Metacritic didn't start reviewing shows till this fall, and usually only reviews new shows.

Did...

did anyone watch last night's episode?

My mind is frakkin' blown.

You know, I watched the mini way back when it premiered, and I thought, "Meh." A season or two later, a buddy of mine was living his life by the show, so I rented S1 and rewatched the mini. It works much better on DVD for me. The mini was spread out over two nights, and I felt no credible intensity from anything in the TV performance, but it worked on DVD. I've watched everything that's been released on DVD. I'll stick with that formula b/c it gives me a show to burn off in a weekend after the release.

I would really like me some new BSG. They can dwell on some minutiae sometimes (the Dee/Lee/Kara/Anders love rectangle could be intolerable sometimes) but the best episodes of BSG are simply amazing. Even one of the episodes that featured the above-mentioned love rectangle (the boxing episode) ended up being sheerly amazing.

It's an uneven show, but at its heights it is sublime. At its lows, it's still tolerable.

So has anyone been watching season 4 as religiously as I have around here?

quote:

Originally posted by Liberalkid:
So has anyone been watching season 4 as religiously as I have around here?

You better frakkin' believe it!

The last episode was spectacular. My favorite of the season.

So, the Final Five are from Earth. That explains why Tyrol, Tigh, Anders, and Tory went around singing Bob Dylan songs at the end of Season 3.

Edit: AV Club has a pretty good blog on this show, if you're interested.

http://www.avclub.com/content/tvclub/show/Battlestar%2BGalactica

This message has been edited. Last edited by: The Fall of Troy,

I might start reading it during the wait for the second half of season 4. But its not so much of a big deal now that they have another series commissioned and yea the last episode was great.

quote:

Originally posted by Liberalkid:
I might start reading it during the wait for the second half of season 4. But its not so much of a big deal now that they have another series commissioned and yea the last episode was great.

Another series???? I had not heard this. Do tell!

Its a prequel entitled Caprica.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caprica_(TV_series)

Upping this, who do people think is the final cylon?

My bets are hedged between Zak Adama, Shaw or Helo.

quote:

Originally posted by Turenne:
Upping this, who do people think is the final cylon?

My bets are hedged between Zak Adama, Shaw or Helo.

It can't be Helo, because that would destroy 4 years of building up Hera as the first cylon/human hybrid.

I won't be Kendra Shaw. She was only in one episode, and the producers said that Razor would not impact the storyline.

I doubt it's Zak Adama. He's never been on the show. That would not have much impact on the viewers or the storyline.

My top suspects:

The priest lady: She recently reappeared in an episode to guide Roslin in visions. When she was alive, she was the single biggest factor in guiding Roslin to the scriptures to lead them to Earth. It would be cool if the final cylon is someone that has been calling the shots behind the scene.

Tom Zarek: Again, he could be someone that was calling the shots behind the scene. His motives have always been questionable.

Doc Coddle: This is a very popular theory. He was responsible for helping the cylons evolve into their skinjob forms. Kind of like a Pinochio sort of thing. This theory gained some credence when Natalie was dying, and she reached out to Coddle as if she knew something. It was a very bizarre scene that could be significant.

Someone on Earth we've never seen before: I'd bet even money on this one. When D'anna saw the Final Five, there was one that she gave a very puzzled look, like she had never seen him/her before. Also, D'anna clearly told Roslin that one of the five was not with the fleet.