Finally ready to post my list, it is straight copy/paste from my blog so I left the descriptions in tact. Enjoy!
1. Belle and Sebastian – “The Life Pursuit”
Dismissed by many critics and listeners as silly pop fluff, I did not enjoy a single album in 2006 more then “The Life Pursuit”. From beautifully crafted pop songs such as “White Collar Boy”, “The Blues are Still Blue”, and “Funny Little Frog” to more melancholy pieces like “Dress Up in You” and “Mornington Crescent”, this album does not misstep in a single place. Murdoch and Co. have released, in my eyes, the best pop album of the last decade. What is even more impressive is that this was a rebound album after the bland “Dear Catastrophe Waitress”, yet B & S did not shy away from the pop melodies present on “Waitress”, but instead expanded them into a complete album absent of stinkers such as “Lord Anthony” and “Roy Walker”. A landmark release that brings a smile to my face every time, I never get sick of a single track.
Key Tracks: All of it, especially “The Blues are Still Blue” and “Funny Little Frog”.
2. The Hold Steady – “Boys and Girls in America”
Expanding their sound from simple bar songs to rock anthems comparable to the Boss, Thin Lizzy, and ZZ Top, The Hold Steady have evolved into the foremost American rock band. With insightful lyrics, courtesy of former Lifter Puller frontman Craig Finn, combined with cutting rock riffs and occasional balladry “Boys and Girls in America” is one of the most complete albums I have heard in years. This album builds on the momentum created by the single “Your Little Hoodrat Friend” released in 2005. Finn has a lyrical gift for creating lyrics that are both profound and relatable while never lapsing into cliché, opening with three power rock anthems “Stuck Between Stations”, “Chips Ahoy”, and “Hot Soft Light” which represent the three strongest consecutive tracks released this year. “First Night” the first ballad on the disc, really represents how far Finn and the boys have come since “Separation Sunday”, chronicling the nostalgia for the first night Finn and friends met Holly (the main character in many Finn songs) and the slow decline of Holly’s life and their friendship thereafter. Though there are two stinkers on this album, “Same Kooks” and “Citrus”, this album is a perfect combination of fun, nostalgia, and wit for my generation of music listeners.
Key Tracks: Everything except “Same Kooks” and “Citrus”.
3. The Decemberists – “The Crane Wife”
“The Crane Wife” represents a major shift in the musical makeup of The Decemberists from baroque pop troubadours to Victorian prog-rockers who are as comfortable with a lyre as an electric guitar. This transformation is especially apparent on the “The Island” three-part track, where Colin Meloy’s distinctive lyrical vocabulary is dashed over epic guitar distortion. “The Island” clocks in at 12:42 much longer than even “The Mariner’s Revenge Song”, yet the song does not drag once nor do the lyrics seem stretched or incompatible with the track. “The Island” is not the only heavy track on the album both “When the War Came” and “The Perfect Crime 2” echo it’s proggy nature. But fear not loyal Decemberists fans there is a lot for you enjoy as well starting with the brilliantly crafted “Yankee Bayonet (I Will Be Home Then)” which is very reminiscent of the baroque craftings of “Picaresque”. Also, if you are lucky to pick up the iTunes extended edition you get the track “The Culling of the Fold” which echoes the gory sentiments of “The Mariners Revenge Song” and has a beautiful, knifing violin part. One of my favorite tracks of the year hands-down.
Key Tracks: “The Culling of the Fold”, “Yankee Bayonet”, “O Valencia”, “Shankill Butchers’
4. Beirut – “Gulag Orkestar”
Simply a brilliant album. At the tender age of 19 Zach Condon has created an album equally likely to be heard in the home of pre-Soviet Jews living in the Pale settlement or in the swanky digs of a Brooklyn hipster. Half Kletzmer music and half Neutral Milk Hotel with a little DeVotchKa added for good measure, “Gulag” is like not album I have ever heard. It easily represents the mixing of Eastern and Western culture, as well as youth and age, this is especially obvious in the track “Scenic World”. Condon will have a long and fruitful career, I am just joyful that I get to witness it.
Key Tracks: “Scenic World”, “Postcards from Italy”, “Mount Wroclai”
5. Destroyer – “Destroyer’s Rubies”
Producing one of the most fluid listening experiences of 2006 was the Dan Bejar side project Destroyer. This album has two of my favorite songs of the year on it: “Watercolours Into the Ocean” and “Painter in Your Pocket”. Both songs showcase Bejar’s free form composition, which creates many beautiful spontaneous moments (along with the occasional dead-end jam). Destroyer was one of the most surprising albums of 2006, since previous Destroyer material has been disappointing and usually overly complex, but with the release of this new album it has the promise to join his other successful groups (The New Pornographers and Swan Lake) as a top band in the art rock community.
Key Tracks: “Painter in Your Pocket”, “Watercolours Into the Ocean”, “European Oils”, “Priest’s Knees”
6. Gnarls Barkley – “St. Elsewhere”
My top summer album. A great combination of funk, soul, rap, and alternative which propelled Cee-Lo and DJ Danger Mouse into the mainstream with the pop-soul hit “Crazy”. Subsequent hit “Gone Daddy Gone” followed in the next month, but the album is in no way limited to those two songs. My favorite songs on the album are the title track, “St. Elsewhere”, a soul-funk track and “The Boogie Monster”. What makes Gnarls Barkley such a great group is their ability to seamlessly move from genre to genre without it feeling forced or awkward. DJ Danger Mouse deserves special praise for creating some of the sickest beats of the year and really taking his work to the next level, putting him in the echelon of elite DJs.
Key Tracks: “Go-Go Gadget Gospel”, “The Boogie Monster”, “St. Elsewhere”
7. Neko Case – “Fox Confessor Brings the Flood”
Neko Case possess one of the most beautiful and powerful voices in music today and on her latest album “Fox Confessor Brings the Flood” she showcases her voice in a way none of her previous albums have managed to do. On tracks such as “John Saw That Number” and “Maybe Sparrow” we see Case’s voice at it’s all time most powerful and beautiful. This album also has much less filler in it than her previous releases, most notably “Blacklisted”, which had some great tracks, but lost it’s flow because of massive amounts of filler. It is unclear what Case’s role in the upcoming New Pornographers’ release, but if she can unleash some of the vocal power that she did on “Fox Confessor Brings the Flood” the New Pornographers will be a much better band for it.
Key Tracks: “Maybe Sparrow”, “Hold On, Hold On”, “John Saw That Number”
8. M. Ward – “Post-War”
A sneaky good album, “Post-War” did not initially impress me as a fantastic release because I saw it as simply a rehash of the superb “Transfiguration of Vincent” not the step forward that I expected from such a gifted musician as Ward. But the more I listened to the album the more it grew on me, as other summer and autumn discs wore on me quickly (especially “Bottoms of Barrels” and “Get Lonely”) tracks such as “Chinese Translation” and “To Go Home” offered more with each listen. The most notable track on the album for me is the criminally underrated “Magic Trick”, which rivaled even a manic band such as Tilly and the Wall in sheer fun factor. A true toe tapper, “Magic Trick”, proved to me that Ward was both capable of chill-out summer folk and head bobbing fun. “Post-War” is also M. Ward’s most complete release, though there is some filler, and shows him putting more emphasis on tracks complimenting each other instead of clashing (as they did on his anemic release “End of Amnesia”). Looking forward to hearing more from him in 2007, even if it comes in collaboration form.
Key Tracks: “Chinese Translation”, “Post-War”, “Magic Trick”
9. Band of Horses – “Everything All the Time”
From the airy vocals to the overall openness of their sound, Band of Horses certainly shook the foundations of the folk-rock world with their first release “Everything All the Time”. Rising from the ashes of Carissa’s Weird, Band of Horses put together a very solid record with some outstanding tracks such as “The Funeral”, “The Great Salt Lake” and “St. Augustine”. “The Funeral” is most definitely the centerpiece track of this album with it’s slow build-up to it’s powerful chorus (“on every occasion/I’m ready for the funeral”) and it’s extremely open feel, it is definitely one of the great indie rock anthems of 2006. But my favorite two songs on the album must be “St. Augustine” and “I Go to the Barn Because I Like the” because I think that Band of Horses does the slow jam better than almost any band in 2006. Both tracks evoke memories of lost love and rebirth. Band of Horses was also a band that I could get into with my friends, which in a year dominated by Joanna Newsom and TV on the Radio was not always easy to come by. Overall, a great chill-out album, which has some misses, but also some terrific hits.
Key Tracks: “St. Augustine”, “The Funeral”, “I Go to the Barn Because I Like the”
10. Magnolia Electric Co. – “Fading Trails”
Dismissed by most critics as a derivative country rock album, I see “Fading Trails” as the beginning of a new direction for Jason Molina. In Molina’s Songs: Ohia days he was too often caught down tempo and favored minimalism over full arrangements (“Ghost Tropic” though an excellent album is an example of this). It is important to note that “Fading Trails” is Southern rock done right, no Doobie Brothers or Lynard Skynard cliché present here, only down and dirty, lyrically driven, Southern rock. “Talk To Me Devil, Again” is the star track on this album, which is a driving rock track, which sees Molina at his best rhythmically and lyrically. Other standouts including “Montgomery” and “Memphis Moon” are also strong lyrical tracks that are even more kick-ass when heard live. This album does have a few stinkers, especially “The Old Horizon” which is a real tempo killer. But it is by far the most solid Magnolia Electric Co. release and with 4 albums slated to come out next year, we should hear much more from them in the near future.
Key Tracks: “Talk to Me Devil, Again”, “Montgomery”, “Memphis Moon”
11. Jenny Lewis and the Watson Twins – “Rabbit Fur Coat”
Key Tracks: “Rise Up, With Fists!!”, “Handle With Care”, “The Big Guns”
12. Joanna Newsom – “Ys”
Key Tracks: “Emily”, “Cosmia”
13. The Essex Green – “Cannibal Sea”
Key Tracks: “Penny and Jack”, “Rue de Lis”, “Elsinore”
14. Regina Spektor – “Begin to Hope”
Key Tracks: “Fidelity”, “Hotel Song”, “Sampson”
15. Camera Obscura – “Let’s Get Out of this Country”
Key Tracks: “Lloyd, I’m Ready to Be Heartbroken”, “Let’s Get Out of This Country”
16. Tom Waits – “Orphans”
Key Tracks: “Lie to Me”, “Sea of Love”
17. Islands – “Return to the Sea”
Key Tracks: “Rough Gem”, “Don’t Call Me Whitney, Bobby”, “Humans”
18. Mates of State – “Bring It Back”
Key Tracks: “Think Long”, “Like U Crazy”
19. Midlake: “The Trials of Van Occupanther”
Key Tracks: “Roscoe”, “Bandits”, “Young Bride”
20. Okkervil River – “Overboard and Down EP”
Key Tracks: “O, Dana”, “The President’s Dead”
I never hated any of you/I loved you all at the time