We talked about doing this in the "Best of 2006: Discussion" thread, so I'm going to take some initiative and actually start it.
Basically, we want a final list of the Best Songs of 2006. I'll volunteer to tally the results. Here are the rules:
1. Make a list of your 30 favorite songs of 2006. You can include more, but I'm only counting your first 30.
2. Unlike the Best Album Lists, we're not using an ordered scoring system. The song that wins is simply the song that shows up with most frequency. If you want to order your list, you can, but #30 will carry the same weight as #1.
3. These are simply songs from 2006 albums. They don't have to be official singles.
4. Use your best judgment in cases like Tom Waits' Orphans where some of the songs were previously released. I'm not going to check all the songs, but “Fall of Troy” is like 10 years old, even though it is a great song.
5. Like the album thread, I'm only counting your list if you've been here for 2 months or have 30 posts (at the time you posted your list).
6. Deadline is January 15th.
I'll try to tally the results in this first post as often as I can.
Post away. Final List:
quote:
The Top 25 Songs of 2006
1.Gnarls Barkley – "Crazy” (26) 2.TV on the Radio - "Wolf Like Me" (24) 3.Band of Horses - “The Funeral” (20) 4.Midlake - “Roscoe” (19) 5.The Hold Steady - “Stuck Between Stations” (14) 6.Hot Chip - “Boy From School” (13) 7.Peter Bjorn and John - "Young Folks" (13) 8.Islands - “Rough Gem” (12) 9.Junior Boys - “In the Morning” (12) 10.Tapes 'n' Tapes – "Insistor" (12) 11.Beirut - “Postcards from Italy” (11) 12.Destroyer - “Rubies” (11) 13.Joanna Newsom - “Emily” (11) 14.Camera Obscura – “Lloyd, I’m ready to be Heartbroken” (10) 15.Cat Power - “The Greatest” (10) 16.The Knife – “Silent Shout” (10) 17.Joanna Newsom – "Cosmia" (9) 18.Liars - "The Other Side of Mt. Heart Attack" (9) 19.T.I. - “What You Know” (9) 20.The Strokes - "You Only Live Once" (9) 21.The Thermals - "A Pillar of Salt" (9) 22.Built to Spill - "Goin' Against Your Mind" (8) 23.Jenny Lewis - "Rise Up, With Fists!!" (8) 24.TV on the Radio - “I Was A Lover” (8) 25.Neko Case - "Hold On, Hold On" & “Star Witness” (TIE) (8)
Honorable Mentions
Belle and Sebastian - "Funny Little Frog" (7) Grizzly Bear - "On a Neck, On a Spit" (7) Muse - "Knights of Cydonia" (7) Muse – "Starlight" (7) Nelly Furtado – "Maneater" (7) The Decemberists - “Yankee Bayonet” (7) The Decemberists - "Sons and Daughters" (7) The Decemberists - “The Island” (7) The Knife - "We Share Our Mothers' Health" (7) The Raconteurs - “Steady as She Goes” (7) Thom Yorke - "Black Swan" (7) Tv on the radio - “Hours” (7) Arctic Monkeys - "A Certain Romance" (6) Belle and Sebastian - "The Blues are Still Blue" (6) Destroyer - "Painter in Your Pocket" (6) Destroyer - “European Oils” (6) Ghostface - "Shakey Dog" (6) Guillemots – “Trains to Brazil” (6) Joanna Newsom - “Sawdust and Diamonds” (6) Justin Timberlake - “My Love” (6) Thom Yorke - “Harrowdown Hill” (6) Yo La Tengo - "Pass the Hatchet, I Think I'm Goodkind" (6)
Contributors: mejis - ericg75 - mark f - philosopherEric - MJmovieluver88 - Musicalifragilistic A.K.A. Il Mago - Cbankerman - Besttasteinmusicever - eggTweedyegg - The Furnace Is Fiery - Chamberk - DrAwesome - bonzob - GG Allin - droganzundt - Craigster - JAB991 - less_success - The_Sprawl - nathanielkt - Jack - sk - Daniel, Esq. - Troy - dildon - Medicated Soap - Mathieu - onFire - Illiniq - The Rabbi - crabsody - dano - FragileKidA - Karen - Carlito's Way - Crazed - Ralph M - Casper - iYa Lo Tengo! - Peewee - outis - SDF - lostyourhead - Borachon - CoCoCo - BContrat - mr_sir - PRG - stereo - Malondron - kelly 1l1 - PrairieFire - Everyoneanindividual - Turenne - Stocky - Jaye H. - Platypus Quest - RavingLunatic - Dork - Vykromond - thomyorkeisgod
This message has been edited. Last edited by: EricG75,
----- I don't dig the Stripes, but I'll go for Har Mar.
Posts: 5104 | Location: Michigan | Registered: 19 June 2005
I like this scoring system best, because I have no idea how to rank 30 songs. Much better to just list ‘em and get it over with. I guess I'll go first: 1. Annuals – Complete or Completing 2. Sol Seppy – Slo Fuzz 3. Sol Seppy – Enter One 4. Richar Buckner – Town 5. Band of Horses – Funeral 6. Band of Horses – The Great Salt Lake 7. M. Ward – To Go Home 8. Centro-matic – Take a Rake 9. Josh Ritter – Girl in the War 10. Midlake – Roscoe 11. Jenny Lewis & the Watson Twins - Born Secular 12. Golden Smog – Another Fine Day 13. Sufjan Stevens – The Mistress Witch from Mclure 14. Sunset Rubdown – They Took a Vote and Said No 15. Thom Yorke – Atoms for Peace 16. Howe Gelb – Paradise Here Abouts 17. Grizzly Bear - COlorado 18. Guillemots – Trains to Brazil 19. The Thermals – Pillar of Salt 20. The Thermals – Power Doesn’t Run on Nothing 21. Margot & the Nuclear So & So’s – Quiet as a Mouse 22. Camera Obscura – Lloyd, I’m ready to be Heartbroken 23. The Twilight Singers – Bonnie Brae 24. The Hold Steady – Southtown Girls 25. The Hold Steady – First Night 26. Peter Bjorn & John – Paris 2004 27. Shearwater – La Dame et la Licorne 28. The Decemberists – The Island, Come and See…. 29. The Decemberists – The Crane Wife 1 & 2 30. Elbow – Station Approach
….and probably 30 more I can’t think of right now.
Posts: 134 | Location: here | Registered: 31 July 2006
Here's mine in glorious alphabetical order (by band name):
Aloha - "Ice Storming" Aloha - "If I Lie Down" Arctic Monkeys - "I Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor" Band of Horses - “The Funeral” Built to Spill - "The Wait" Built to Spill - “Goin' Against Your Mind” Cat Power - “Lived in Bars” Eagles of Death Metal - "The Ballad of Queen Bee and Baby Duck" Gnarls Barkley - "Crazy" Goldfrapp - “Number 1” Jolie Holland - "A Crush in the Ghetto" Joseph Arthur - "Too Much to Hide Liars - "The Other Side of Mt. Heart Attack" Nelly Furtado - "Maneater" Oxford Collapse - “Loser City” Pearl Jam - "Come Back" Phoenix - "Rally" Regina Spektor - “Summer in the City” Tapes 'N Tapes - "Cowbell" The Hold Steady - "Chill Out Tent" The Hold Steady - "First Night" The Minus 5 - "Cemetery Row" The Sleepy Jackson - "You Needed More" The Thermals - "A Pillar of Salt" The Thermals - "Here's Your Future" The Walkmen - “Louisiana” TV on the Radio - "Snakes and Martyrs" TV on the Radio - "Wolf Like Me" Twilight Singers - "Bonnie Brae" Wilderness - "Monumental"
----- I don't dig the Stripes, but I'll go for Har Mar.
Posts: 5104 | Location: Michigan | Registered: 19 June 2005
"You Only Live Once" by the Strokes "A World of Hurt" by Drive-By Truckers "Little Things" by Los Lobos "Nancy Reagan's Head" by Mission of Burma "Old Dan Tucker" by Bruce Springsteen "The Levee's Gonna Break" by Bob Dylan "Goin' Against Your Mind" by Built to Spill "Girl in Saskatoon" by Johnny Cash "Break This Time" by Alejandro Escovedo "Melt Your Heart" by Jenny Lewis with the Watson Twins "Here's Your Future" by the Thermals "Love and Communication" by Cat Power "I Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor" by the Arctic Monkeys "Jeez Louise" by Grandaddy "The W.A.N.D." by the Flaming Lips "Black Cadillac" by Rosanne Cash "A Method" by TV on the Radio "Thou Shalt Wilt" by Loose Fur "Radar Man" by Frank Black "Cosmia" by Joanna Newsom "Atoms For Peace" by Thom Yorke "Hot Soft Light" by the Hold Steady "Shankhill Butchers" by the Decemberists "The Iliad" by Tapes 'n Tapes "Wicked World" by Jon Auer "Strange Desire" by the Black Keys "Strange Apparition" by Beck "Darling We're Out of Time" by Cracker "Reena" by Sonic Youth "Pass the Hatchet, I Think I'm Goodkind" by Yo La Tengo
This message has been edited. Last edited by: mark f,
"Naked Woman, Naked Man Where did you get that nice sun tan?"
Posts: 12865 | Location: Behind the Orange Curtain | Registered: 14 May 2004
1. “Bonnie Brae” Twilight Singers 2. “Stuck Between Stations” Hold Steady 3. “Massive Nights” Hold Steady 4. “Summersong” The Decemberists 5. “Do It Again Again” The Tyde 6. “Visit from the Dead Dog” Ed Harcourt 7. “Penny on the Train Track” Ben Kweller 8. “When You Were Young” The Killers 9. “Become The Enemy” Lemonheads 10. “Roscoe” Midlake 11. “Wish You Well” Bernard Fanning 12. “Skip to the End” The Futureheads 13. “I Don’t Wanna Be The One” Lucero 14. “Skeleton Key” Margot and the Nuclear So and So’s 15. “Jen is Bringin’ the Drugs” Margot and the Nuclear So and So’s 16. “I Got You” The Damnwells 17. “Golden Days” The Damnwells 18. “You Used To Drive Me Around” Jon Auer 19. “Corvette” Golden Smog 20. “Somerville” The Pernice Brothers 21. “Nine Good Fingers” White Whale 22. “Long Red Bottle of Wine” Michael Carpenter 23. “Funeral" Band of Horses 24. “Rise Up With Fists!!!" Jenny Lewis 25. “My Valentine” Rhett Miller 26. “Help Me Suzanne” Rhett Miller 27. “Degrees of Separation” Badly Drawn Boy 28. “Hey Lloyd, I’m Ready to Be Heartbroken” Camera Obscura 29. “Welcome to The Black Parade” My Chemical Romance 30. “Good Man” Josh Ritter
This message has been edited. Last edited by: philosopherEric,
Posts: 3875 | Location: ATL, GA | Registered: 25 May 2004
MarkF, I think the Thermals are going to have enough support, you didn't need to list Here's Your Future twice. Nice to see someone else likes A Method. I dig it too, though maybe not quite top 30 for me.
1. Crazy - Gnarls Barkley (instant classic) 2. Rough Gem - Islands 3. Emily - Joanna Newsom 4. Shut Up I am Dreaming of Places Where Lovers Have Wings - Sunset Rubdown 5. Rubies - Destroyer 6. Did I Step On Your Trumpet - Danielson 7. Here's Your Future - The Thermals 8. European Oils - Destroyer 9. Vein of Stars - Flaming Lips 10. Elevator Music - Beck 11. Cope - Futureheads 12. In the Morning - Junior Boys 13. 3 Legged Animals - Califone 14. Trill - Clipse 15. Swans - Islands 16. Fair - Annuals 17. FM - Junior Boys 18. Wolf Like Me - TV on the Radio 19. Back to the Sea - Thermals 20. Harrowdown Hill - Thom Yorke 21. Pass the Hatchet, I Think I'm Goodkind 22. Stuck Between Stations - Hold Steady 23. Louisiana - The Walkmen 24. Stadiums and Shrines II - Sunset Rubdown 25. Boy From School - Hot Chip 26. Maybe Sparrow - Neko Case 27. O Mexico - Dosh 28. The Other Side of Mt. Heart Attack - Liars 29. Sway - Annuals 30. Something Isn't Right - Herbert
------------------------
I fell in love with the first cute girl that I met.
Posts: 738 | Location: Nova Scotia | Registered: 31 May 2006
Originally posted by Musicalifragilistic: MarkF, I think the Thermals are going to have enough support, you didn't need to list Here's Your Future twice. Nice to see someone else likes A Method. I dig it too, though maybe not quite top 30 for me.
Ha! Good catch. I forgot to add the rule that you can only list a song once in your list. I won't count it twice just because you list it twice. Even if it is a good song
----- I don't dig the Stripes, but I'll go for Har Mar.
Posts: 5104 | Location: Michigan | Registered: 19 June 2005
Annuals - Brother Beirut - Postcards From Italy Built To Spill - Goin' Against Your Mind Cold War Kids - Hospital Beds Destroyer - Painter In Your Pocket Destroyer - Rubies The Fiery Furnaces - Benton Harbor Blues The Fiery Furnaces - Teach Me Sweetheart The Figurines - The Wonder The Futureheads - Skip to the End Gnarls Barkley - Crazy The Guillemots - Trains to Brazil Hot Chip - And I Was A Boy From School Junior Boys - In the Morning The Lovely Feathers - Breakfast Cake M. Ward - To Go Home Man Man - Van Helsing Boombox Neko Case - Star Witness Peter Bjorn & John - Young Folks Phoenix - Sometimes In the Fall The Rapture - Don Gon Do It The Rapture - W.A.Y.U.H. Sound Team - Movie Monster The Strokes - You Only Live Once Sunset Rubdown - Shut Up I Am Dreaming Of Places Where Lovers Have Wings Sunset Rubdown - Us Ones In Between Tapes n' Tapes - In Houston Voxtrot - Mothers, Sisters, Daughters & Wives Voxtrot - Soft & Warm The Walkmen - All Hands And The Cook
Posts: 68 | Location: Littleton, CO | Registered: 05 July 2005
I know we are not counting higher ranked songs more than others, but I'm going to go ahead and make a top 30 list ending with my favorite song of the year. I know it's tough (I mean is there really much difference between song 16 and 17), but this is, as best I could, my favorite 30 songs of the year (in order). 30. Another Sunny Day-Belle and Sebastian 29. Rubies-Destroyer 28. Just a Thought-Gnarls Barkley 27. Maggie-Cracker 26. Trains to Brazil-The Guillemots 25. Chelsea Dagger-The Fratelli's 24. Fake Tales of San Francisco-Arctic Monkeys 23. The Wonder-The Figurines 22. Valerie-The Zutons 21. Insistor-Tapes N'Tapes 20. Funeral-Band of Horses 19. The Gulag Orkestar-Beirut 18. Wolf Like Me-TV on the Radio 17. Scenic World-Beirut 16. Long Summer Day-Two Gallants 15. The Dugout-Ladyhawk 14. Young Bride-Midlake 13. Jenny, don't be hasty-Paolo Nutini 12. On a neck, on a spit-Grizzly Bear 11. Sawdust and Diamonds-Joanna Newsom 10. European Oils-Destroyer 9. Wish you well-Bernard Fanning 8. And I was a boy from School-Hot Chip 7. Emily-Joanna Newsom 6. For Wicked Gil (the slow version, not the album version)-Band of Horses 5. I was a lover-TV on the Radio 4. He who flattened your flame is getting torched-Danielson 3. Look after Me-Hot Chip 2. Crazy-Gnarls Barkley (became underrated because it got so popular, if that makes any sense) 1. Roscoe-Midlake (favorite song of the year)
Ready to hear criticism now. Tough to make a list of 30 songs and rank them.
In no particular order. Those with a (*) are my favorites:
T.I. - What you know?* Thom Yorke - and it rained all night* Thom Yorke - Cymbal rush AFI - The Interview AFI - Killing time Kid Koala - slew test 2 Dumas - Fixer le temps* Dumas - Alors alors Malajube - Fille à Plumes Mono - The remains of the day* Loose Fur - Apostolic The Knife - Neverland The Knife - Forest family TV on the radio - hours The raconteurs - steady as she goes Flaming lips - the WAND Low - Monkey* Low - Pissing J Dilla - lightworks Oneida - Up with people Peaches - Downtown* Peaches - Fuck or kill Red Hot Chili Peppers - Snow Justin Timberlake feat. T.I. - My love Junior Boys - In the morning Lady sovereign - Love me or hate me
...I don't have 30 songs but I can't think of other songs as great as these ones for the moment.
In the very bottom right corner of each post, on the same line as your post number (if it's there), you will see a file folder with a pencil eraser on it. Click on that and edit away.
"Naked Woman, Naked Man Where did you get that nice sun tan?"
Posts: 12865 | Location: Behind the Orange Curtain | Registered: 14 May 2004
In the very bottom right corner of each post, on the same line as your post number (if it's there), you will see a file folder with a pencil eraser on it. Click on that and edit away.
Cool, Thanks.
Posts: 877 | Location: santa barbara | Registered: 02 November 2006
2. The Greatest - Cat Power 3. Desecration Smile - Red Hot Chili Peppers 4. Black Flowers - Yo La Tengo 5. Rag for William S Burroughs - Matmos 6. Three County Highway - Indigo Girls 7. Manitoba/Cowbell - Tapes N Tapes 8. Could We - Cat Power 9. The Funeral -Band Of Horses 10. Bridge To Nowhere - Sam Roberts
11. Bells - Vitalic & Linda Lamb 12. Cellphone's Dead - Beck 13. Not Ready To Make Nice - Dixie Chicks 14. Harrowdown Hill - Thom Yorke 15. And I Was A Boy From School - Hot Chip 16. Lucifer's Memory - Comets On Fire 17. The Great Salt Lake - Band of Horses 18. Maybe Sparrow - Neko Case 19. Warung Beach - John Digweed 20. Mr. Ambulance Driver - The Flaming Lips 21. Travel Is Dangerous 0 Mogwai 22. Benton Harbour Blues - Fiery Furnaces 23. Wayward % Parliament - Amy Millan 24. My Love - Justin Timberlaake 25. Today - Isolee
"the sun gets passed from sea to sea, silently, and back to me"
Posts: 739 | Location: middle of bf nowhere | Registered: 25 January 2005