For those who care or not, here are the various results.

I agreed with them on two of our respective Top Ten picks. We agreed on Loretta Lynn and Brian Wilson. (I usually agree on about 5/6.)

This message has been edited. Last edited by: mark f,

You all can refer back to past posts for my negative opinions on the College Dropout.

Quite a predictable list to someone who's been reading music reviews throughout the entire year. I guess by design, that's what should happen.

So much there, it's hard to say anything comprehensive. I was thrilled to see Rilo Kiley come in so high (14!) and thought the Killers got in much higher than they deserved. R.E.M.'s lackadaisical Around the Sun didn't deserved its #89 spot (beating out Annie!).

I was notably happy to see two of MY faves, Kevin Tihista (at 490) and Maplewood (702) make the list. I didn't think ANYONE, not even nerdy music critics, heard those records.

I owned 11 of their Top 40, including 5 of the top 10.

Well, I tend to use the pazz n jop lists to hear about albums I don't know exist, so naturally my list is going to be slanted a bit toward this one.

But, as far as top ten goes, I agree with Arcade Fire, Loretta Lynn, Modest Mouse, Franz Ferdinand, and Brain Wilson.