quote:

Originally posted by ReddSax:
I'd vote for Brawl, but uhh... I believe it's spelled B-R-A-W-L, not S-U-P-E-R-M-A-R-I-O-G-A-L-A-X-Y.

Another thing: I'm sure you know this, but technically, some of these games aren't from 2008. Maybe I misunderstood the idea of the contest, but SMG and MP3 are 2007.

Oh, and one last thing...

What do you mean MK Wii didn't have an average of over 9/10? It should've, I think... but that's not your fault.

... Or is it?

quote:

Originally posted by fredthenerd:
Super Mario Galaxy and Metroid Prime 3: Corruption are games from 2007, not 2008.

quote:

I know Metroid Prime 3 is not from the year 2008, but like that we will have more choices.

quote:

Originally posted by Dark_Cornatus:
Of the list ive played and finished the first 5 games.
The best is hard to decide!

Mario Galaxy
Great game, not as fun as Mario 64, but still a great game. However, it needed extras, like something to do not in the planets. It was too much of getting stars, and not having as much fun with freedom.

Smash bros Brawl
A bit overhyped, they toned down the stronger characters, and made the weaker ones better, the items are terrible, i really think they have gone too far with them, i need to always set them to low appearance, the online mode is SHIT! The characters i unlocked in like 3 days??? All without trying or knowing how to unlock them. Yet to unlock trophies, it can take hours of gameplay on end to rack up 20 matches of time, and they are useless. It took me ages to unlock all 4 characters on 64 version. However, great levels, and some decent extras, like stage builder, masterpieces, etc. Also some bad ones. However, the biggest letdown for smash bros was the lack of an overall easy to read stat screen from brawl battles, they have the top 5 and a zoomed in kind of version, but not as nice as the 64 versions. Still a great game though.

Zelda TP
Pretty typical Zelda game, much like the old ones, but it was what i expected and a good game.

World Of Goo
Great little game, i had alot of fun though FAR too short to be rated as high. A game needs longevity to be the best, this doesnt.

Resident Evil Wii
I was totally addicted to this game, fantastic storyline for a genre of shooter i hate. The worst thing about it was the whole headshot problem.... totally ruined the brlliance of the game.

So there you go, each game has definate flaws, i think my vote will go with Mario Galaxy, at least it was fresh.

quote:

Originally posted by DukethePCDR:
Poor Metroid Not much love on this forum. I like Metroid, but I prefer the 2-D side scrollers. I picked Okami because it's the most unique of the ones on your list.