I was just browsing some older films and noticed that they were missing from the ATHS list even though they seemed to fit the criteria - score, # of reviews, etc.

Au Hasard Balthazar 100 (8 reviews)
Pepe Le Moko 98 (12 reviews)

By contrast, Werckmeister Harmonies is ranked Number 17 even though it is only 92 (8 reviews)

The list of critics differs on each film, of course, but there does not appear to be an overwhelming difference in the quality of the sources. Seems like the the ranking algorithm is deranged.

Comments?

Let's not forget that Seven Samurai has a 99 yet is no where to be found.

Could someone please, please search the reviews for the following movies:
citizen kane
gandhi
the color purple

I agree about Citizen Kane.
It's about time for it to be added to the database!