la Vie en Rose (Olivier Dahan, 2007, Grade: B-)
I've watched this film twice and I may watch it again. Originally, I gave it a higher rating, mainly because Marion Cotillard delivers such an awesome performance as Edith Piaf. My wife loves Edith Piaf, so I've been exposed to her in the last 20 years much more than I was in the preceding 30, even though I could
name her voice in ONE note way back when. Then, I started to wonder if this film really is any better than
Ray or
Walk the Line just because it's in French. I decided that it's still well worth watching, but aside from the central performance and some spectacular makeup, it's not ALL THAT super. However, I am pulling for Marion to snag the Best Actress Oscar.
Across the Universe (Julie Taymor, 2007, Grade: B-)
The strangest thing to me about this semi-strange movie is that the script was written by the 70-year-old tag team of vets Dick Clement and Ian La Frenais. That totally caught me off guard. Even so, I was pretty impressed with the film. Compared to messes like
Help!, Magical Mystery Tour, Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, Tommyand
Pink Floyd: The Wall, this film actually tells a relatively coherent story which covers much of the history of the 1960s. In that way, it reminds me of Milos Forman's
Hair. I probably would have given it a higher rating, but about halfway through (somewhere around the time that Bono played Doctor Robert as a cross between Robin Williams and Ken Kesey; then Eddie Izzard took a few too many liberties with "Being For the Benefit of Mr. Kite"), I started thinking that it was going to be TOO LONG. Even so, it does right its way toward the end. However, Evan Rachel Ward does prove herself to be a fine singer, and she keeps getting more beautiful as the years pass. Plus Julie Taymor is a master visualist.
The Assassination of Jesse James By the Coward Robert Ford (Andrew Dominik, 2007, Grade: C+, benefit of a doubt)
I find this to be a boring, pretentious art-western which can't touch the unshined shoes of last year's
3:10 to Yuma. It has none of the poetry of Malick's
Days of Heaven (despite the presence of Sam Shepard as an attenuated Frank James) and none of the insane genius of Cimino's
Heaven's Gate, yet it seems to think that it does. For the first two-thirds of the film, the characters and dialogue seem to be almost entirely inconsequential. This film can't even compare to Henry King's
Jesse James (1939) and Fritz Lang's superior sequel,
The Return of Frank James (1940).
However, the reason I will rewatch it is that the final third did actually provide some suspense and characterization, as well as providing info which I believe is not found in any other film. To me, the best thing about the film is Brad Pitt's performance. It may well be his finest. He blows Casey Affleck out of the water, although I was impressed with the younger Affleck's turn in
Gone Baby Gone. The much-lauded cinematography didn't especially impress me, except for a few brief scenes involving shadows extending across the landscape, train interiors, houses, etc. I actually believe that Deakins did a better job with
No Country For Old Men. However, I am rewatching it again this week, so if I feel the need to correct myself, I'll come back and you can tell me, "I told you so!"
Gone Baby Gone (Ben Affleck, 2007, Grade: B)
I watched it last night. This was much better than Mystic River, which I give a
C+ at most, although when this film started out, I wasn't totally convinced. I was almost having a complete flashback to the earlier film for awhile, but all of a sudden, this film came much more to life. This film's overall mystery was much more complex than
Mystic River's. I'll admit that if you're awake, there is only one way to interpret some of the incident at the "lake", and that leads a certain direction, but you can't understand where it all will eventually take you. Even before that scene, there was some good suspense; this film did have many tense, exciting moments to go with its moral ambiguity.
As the film twists and turns back upon itself, it maintains all the audience's first impressions of the characters, but deepens most of them to show how things are never that black and white, but really that painful cliché of shades of gray. The verisimilitude of the film adds immeasurably to its quality. Kudos to director/co-scriptor Ben Affleck for using so many true Bostonian people and locations throughout the film. I haven't really mentioned the performances, but I thought that Casey Affleck was much more powerful here than in his nominated turn as
The Coward Robert Ford. Amy Ryan obviously deserves her Best Supporting nom, and it's just a pleasure to see veterans Ed Harris, John Ashton, Morgan Freeman and Amy Madigan doing their best in something they obviously believe in.
"Naked Woman, Naked Man
Where did you get that nice sun tan?"